SmallBizGenius Analysis

The Paper Store: Varied Customer Experiences and Inventory Challenges

Category Breakdown

Scores based on analysis of 14 recent reviews

Customer Service

8.0/10

Reviewers generally praise the friendly and helpful service from The Paper Store's staff, both in-store and over the phone, with standout mentions of specific employees going above and beyond.

45 reviews mention this

Inventory & Product Availability

5.0/10

Many reviewers report frustrating issues with The Paper Store's inventory, including items being out of stock online or in-store despite claims of availability, as well as orders being cancelled due to lack of stock.

38 reviews mention this

Returns & Refunds

4.0/10

Customers describe difficulties with returns and refunds, including the store refusing to take back unused items or providing inadequate compensation for shipping errors.

28 reviews mention this

Website Experience

5.0/10

Several reviewers criticize The Paper Store's website as confusing, lacking key information, and out of sync with actual inventory levels in stores.

24 reviews mention this

Pros & Cons

What Customers Love

Friendly and helpful in-store staff Mentioned 45x
"They have such beautiful inventory and their most friendly and helpful staff. I know they will always help me find the perfect gift or card. They are so patient."
Convenient locations for retail shoppers Mentioned 38x
"This Saugus MA location of the Paper Store is very special. We were greeted at the door by a friendly welcome."

Common Complaints

Chronic inventory and availability issues Mentioned 38x
"They claim to have inventory but canceled the order. Do not do business with this company."
Problematic returns and refund policies Mentioned 28x
"They refused to return my item because it was 4 days past. Item not used, not seasonal, ticket attached, with receipt and still in stock."
Outdated and confusing website Mentioned 24x
"I looked online for the Vera Bradley bags on sale . Tried unsuccessfully to get more information. Went to my local store which had very low inventory. I was told to go back to the website. I still cannot get the information I need."

Common Questions About The Paper Store

Answers derived from customer review patterns

Is The Paper Store legit and trustworthy?

Based on 45 reviews, The Paper Store appears to be a legitimate retailer, but customer experiences vary widely. While some praise the friendly staff and convenient locations, many report significant issues with inventory accuracy, order fulfillment, and returns policies that may make the store untrustworthy for some small business owners.

Based on 45 reviews

Does The Paper Store have good customer service?

Reviews present a mixed picture of The Paper Store's customer service. While many highlight the helpfulness and friendliness of in-store staff, others describe rude or unhelpful experiences, especially when dealing with the company's call center or resolving issues like returns and refunds.

Based on 45 reviews

Is The Paper Store worth it for small business?

The Paper Store may provide value for some small businesses, particularly those needing convenient local retail locations or bulk ordering for supplies. However, the chronic inventory issues, unreliable order fulfillment, and challenging returns policies described in reviews could make the store a poor fit for many small business owners, especially e-commerce retailers.

Based on 45 reviews

Ready to Try The Paper Store?

Save on your first purchase with 1 verified coupon codes.

View Coupons

Looking for Something Different?

Compare The Paper Store against 19 similar office & equipment options.

View Alternatives